Preserving original brick, mortar, and craftsmanship—without compromising structural integrity.
Preservation Matters
Historic Masonry Requires a Different Approach
Historic brick buildings were constructed with materials and methods very different from modern masonry. Improper repairs—especially with hard Portland cement mortars—can trap moisture, accelerate brick failure, and cause irreversible damage.
At McGinley’s Masonry Repair, we understand how historic structures were built and how to repair them without compromising their integrity or character.
Historically Compatible Materials
Lime-based, breathable mortars compatible with historic brick—including traditional Type O formulations where appropriate.
Selective, Minimal Demolition
Only deteriorated mortar and failed brick are removed, avoiding unnecessary demolition and loss of original material.
Traditional Craftsmanship
Hand-tooled joints carefully matched to original profiles, texture, and finish.
Preservation-First Repairs
Repairs are designed to stabilize and protect the structure—not over-restore or erase its historic character.
Selective Tuckpointing
- Removal of deteriorated mortar only
- Color, texture, and joint-profile matching
- Breathable mortar to protect original brick
Brick Stabilization & Structural Repairs
- Failed sections rebuilt with salvaged or matched brick
- Wall bracing and stabilization where needed
- Elevated and difficult-access repairs
Historic Chimney Repair
- Chimney rebuilds using period-appropriate methods
- Crown, flashing, and masonry corrections
- Preservation-compliant solutions
Historic Masonry Restoration & Repair FAQ’s
Historic brick buildings were constructed using softer brick and lime-based mortars designed to flex and breathe. Modern masonry materials, particularly hard Portland cement mortars, can trap moisture and cause historic brick to crack or deteriorate. Historic masonry repair requires compatible materials and techniques to avoid long-term damage.
Yes. Most historic masonry projects require lime-based or historically compatible mortars that allow moisture to escape naturally. Using the correct materials helps protect the original brick and ensures repairs age properly with the structure.
By default, this panel is concealed and appears when the user clicks on the section title. Input relevant information about its title using paragraphs or bullet points. Accordions can enhance the user experience when utilized effectively. They allow users to choose what they want to read and disregard the rest. Accordions are often utilized for frequently asked questions (FAQs).
Our goal is to preserve the original appearance of the structure whenever possible. Mortar color, texture, and joint profiles are carefully matched so repairs blend with existing masonry rather than standing out.
Yes. We regularly work on older and historically significant buildings and understand the importance of preservation-focused repairs. We can provide clear documentation and scopes of work to support historic district or preservation review processes when required.
Our Historic Masonry Repair & Preservation Process
Assessment & Consultation
Every historic structure is different. We carefully evaluate the masonry, identify the cause of deterioration, and recommend repairs that preserve the building’s integrity and character.
Preservation-Focused Plan
Scope is limited to what truly needs repair—no unnecessary demolition.
Careful Execution
Historic repairs are completed using compatible materials, proper curing methods, and careful workmanship to protect surrounding original masonry.
Clean Finish & Review
Every repair is reviewed for structural integrity, visual consistency, and long-term performance before the project is considered complete.
Historic masonry repairs performed to restore as much of this pre-Civil War era home using the original brick that was hand-made on the property.
Several historic masonry repairs were performed on this pre-Civil War era home using the original brick that was hand-made on the property and preserved for over 160 years.
Charles is carefully demolishing a bowed brick foundation in Historic Irvington to rebuild using salvaged brick.
Tuckpointing repair performed on historic brick in the Historic Irvington neighborhood.
Careful demolition of historic brick foundation in Irvington prior to rebuilding using original brick and historic techniques.
Historic brick foundation repair performed in Irvington, Indianapolis, IN
Historic masonry repair performed in several areas of this home in Fortville, Indiana
Historic masonry repair performed to back step in Historic Irvington.
Tuckpointing repair performed on historic brick in the Historic Irvington neighborhood.
Tuckpointing repair performed on historic brick in the Historic Irvington neighborhood.
Why Clients Trust McGinley’s for Historic Masonry Restoration
- Specialized experience with historic homes and masonry structures
- Proper mortar selection, including traditional lime-based mortars when appropriate
- Preservation-first philosophy that avoids unnecessary replacement
- Careful matching of brick, mortar color, texture, and joint profiles
- Honest recommendations focused on long-term performance
- Meticulous craftsmanship that respects the original architecture
- Fully insured, and locally owned in Central Indiana
Why Homeowners & Property Managers Trust McGinley’s Masonry Repair for historic masonry repair
Historic masonry requires more than skilled bricklaying—it requires an understanding of how older buildings were originally constructed and how they are meant to perform. Using modern materials or improper repair methods can trap moisture, accelerate deterioration, and permanently alter the character of a historic home.
At McGinley’s Masonry Repair, we specialize in preserving the craftsmanship and integrity of historic brick and stone structures throughout Central Indiana. From pre-Civil War homes to early 20th-century commercial buildings, we carefully evaluate each project to determine the appropriate repair methods, mortar composition, and replacement materials before any work begins.
Whenever possible, we preserve original masonry rather than replacing it. When replacement is necessary, we work to match existing brick, mortar color, texture, and joint profiles so repairs blend naturally with the surrounding structure. Our goal is to leave your building structurally sound while maintaining the character that makes it historically significant.
Whether we’re carefully repointing original brickwork, rebuilding a deteriorated chimney, repairing a stone foundation, or restoring decorative masonry details, we approach every historic restoration with the respect these buildings deserve.
As a locally owned and operated masonry business, we personally oversee every historic repair project from assessment through completion. Our work is not subcontracted or rushed—decisions are made on site with accountability to our clients and our community.
As owners of an 1895 home ourselves, we understand the responsibility of preserving historic masonry. We regularly repair older homes, commercial buildings, and designated historic properties throughout Central Indiana.
It sounds a little more polished.
Our estimates are based on what the structure actually needs to remain stable and protected. We clearly identify any structural or preservation-related repairs and discuss cosmetic or optional work separately, allowing clients to decide without pressure. Our role is to explain the options—not to upsell—so clients can make informed decisions that fit their goals and budget.
Many historic repairs take place while homes or buildings remain occupied. We work carefully, protect surrounding areas, minimize disruption, and maintain clean, organized job sites throughout the repair process.
Clients receive clear scopes of work, written documentation, and straightforward communication before, during, and after the project. This transparency is especially important for historic properties, property managers, and approval processes.
Curious about your home’s history?
Many Indianapolis homes and buildings have fascinating histories that go far beyond their brickwork. Learning when your home was built, how it was used, or how it has changed over time can add real context to restoration and repair decisions.
We’ve used this guide ourselves and uncovered some genuinely interesting stories along the way.
You don’t have to live with this. McGinley’s Masonry Repair can help you restore your historic brick beautifully.
Get a Free Historic Masonry Repair Estimate
If your historic brick or mortar is showing signs of deterioration, our experienced masonry team can help protect and restore your home.
McGinley’s Masonry Repair specializes in historic masonry repair, preservation, and restoration throughout Indianapolis and Central Indiana.